And now, the Tony Race is over. Let’s take a look at how we did, and who made it on the list of 2016’s top Tony Pundits.
We are pleased to announce that our predictions were the most accurate of any theater publication for the second year in a row! Take a look at this year’s Handicapping the Tony Race series to read more about how we came to our predictions.
Note with these rankings that not all of these experts published predictions for all 24 categories. To accommodate for this, our rankings are weighted by the total number of categories each expert made predictions for. Also note that this year, with Hamilton having such a secure hold on so many categories, the variance among theater experts is very low.
| #1 |  Oliver Roth(OHenry Productions) |
20/24 83% |
 Chris Schembra(OHenry Productions) |
20/24 83% |
|
| #3 |  Gordon Cox(Variety) |
19/21 90% |
| #4 | 
Krista Ray |
19/24 79% |
|
|
19/24 79% |
|
Lee Seymour |
19/24 79% |
|
Adam Feldman & David Cote |
19/24 79% |
|
Jesse Green |
19/24 79% |
|
| #9 | 
Robert Hofler |
18/23 87% |
| #10 |  Linda Winer(Newsday) |
15/17 88% |
| #11 |  Jeremy Gerard(Deadline) |
15/24 63% |
| #12 |  Ben Brantley(New York Times) |
14/16 88% |
| #13 | 
Ken Davenport |
14/24 58% |
| #14 |  Charles Isherwood(New York Times) |
13/16 81% |
| #15 | 
Peter Marks |
12/12 100% |
| #16 |  Alexis Soloski (The Guardian) |
12/17 71% |
| #17 |  Naveen Kumar (Towleroad) |
11/12 92% |
| #18 | 
Scott Feinberg |
11/14 79% |
| #19 |  Carey Beth Elder (The Huffington Post) |
11/15 67% |
| #20 | 
Roma Torre |
10/10 100% |
Join the conversation